About Oddity

You can't know an agency from its pitch.

Oddity is an independent agency search and matchmaking partner for mid-market brands. We know agencies from watching them work, and we introduce you to the three to five that fit your brief. It costs brands nothing.

A man in a pinstripe suit looking through a red magnifying glass

“You can only know it from someone who has been watching it work.”

The Oddity premise

$0

for brands, start to finish

3–5

agencies on each shortlist

2–4 wks

from brief to shortlist

110+

creative leadership roles filled a year

Why Oddity exists

There are thousands of agencies. They all look capable.

Every case study impresses and every pitch says “different.” The hard part isn’t finding agencies. It’s knowing which ones are right for your brief, your budget and your team.

That knowledge isn’t in a database or a pitch deck. It comes from knowing agency leaders, watching agencies work, and talking to the brands that hired them.

Oddity brings that knowledge to one decision: the right independent agency for your brand, right now.

How it works

We start with your business, not our network.

STEP 1

The brief

We talk through your challenge, your team’s working style, what has and hasn’t worked before, and what success looks like. A formal brief helps but isn’t required.

One conversation

STEP 2

The shortlist

We pick three to five independent agencies for relevant work and team fit, not profile views, and explain why each one made the list.

2–4 weeks

STEP 3

The introduction

We introduce you to each agency personally and brief both sides, so the first call is a working session, not a pitch.

Personal intros

STEP 4

You choose

You negotiate scope, pricing and terms directly with the agency you pick. If none feels right, tell us and we keep looking.

Your call

Who’s in the network

Every agency passes three gates before we'd ever put it in front of you.

The result is a network of small to mid-sized independent agencies that do the work and get results.

i.

Invited, referred or applied

Agencies come to us by invitation, referral or application.

ii.

Accepted on strict criteria

Each agency is reviewed against Oddity’s acceptance criteria before it joins.

iii.

Confirmed by the people they work with

Existing clients and vendors vouch for them before they’re in.

What it costs

Free for brands. Never pay-to-play for agencies.

For brands

$0

No fee to use Oddity for agency matchmaking.

You don’t pay to submit a brief.

You don’t pay to receive recommendations.

You don’t pay for introductions.

For agencies

Membership gets an agency considered. Fit gets it recommended.

Our agency network funds the model through membership fees and a success-based commission when business is won.

Agencies pay for

Being part of the network

A commission on business won

Agencies never pay for

Introductions, rankings, placement, or a spot on your shortlist

Being in the network makes an agency eligible.Fit decides whether we recommend it.

What Oddity isn’t

If you've hired an agency before, you've probably tried these.

A directory

You don’t search hundreds of profiles and figure it out yourself.

An RFP platform

We don’t try to put as many agencies as possible into your pitch.

Pay-to-play

Agencies can’t buy their way onto your shortlist.

An agency

We aren’t selling you our own creative services.

We’re the people you call when you need to find the people who will.

Jonathan Wilson

The people behind the shortlist

“Mid-market brands make complex agency decisions without the procurement teams, budgets or access enterprise brands have. Oddity is built for them.”

Jonathan Wilson founded Oddity after 14 years leading growth at creative, media and experiential agencies. He built and sold Big Pixel, led North American growth for Anomaly, and managed revenue across a $40M+ agency portfolio.

Jonathan Wilson

Founder & CEO · Ex-Anomaly, Head of Business Development, North America

The Oddity team

Former agency founders, agency operators and in-house marketing leaders. Between us we’ve diagnosed briefs, priced engagements, led pitches and grown accounts, so we know what to look for beyond the portfolio.

Jenna Hoffman

Jenna Hoffman

COO, Brand Partnerships

Ex-Fidelity, In-House Marketing Director

Mariah Davidson

Mariah Davidson

Managing Director, Kinly

Ex-Ogilvy, LA Director of Ops

Rachael Klein

Rachael Klein

Head of People

Ex-Dentsu NYC, Recruiter/HR

Joel Carter

Joel Carter

Brand Strategy (Fractional)

Carter Collective

Dan Freeman

Dan Freeman

Brand Partnerships (Fractional)

Experience beyond the agency world

Michelle Rowe

Michelle Rowe

Brand Partnerships Ambassador

Ex-Latitude, Head of Growth

Mission

To give mid-market brand leaders a faster, smarter path to the right independent agency partner, through personally curated shortlists built on firsthand knowledge of carefully vetted agencies. Free to the brand, success-based with the agency, and always honest.

Vision

A marketing industry where mid-market brands get the agency intelligence once reserved for Fortune 500 procurement teams, and find the right independent agency without six weeks of process, six-figure fees, or six months of regret.

Values

What we hold ourselves to.

Depth over volume

What we know about each agency is the product. The number of agencies isn’t.

Honest over polished

We’ll tell a brand when an agency isn’t the right fit, and tell an agency when a brand isn’t the right client.

Independence

No agency pays to appear on a shortlist. No brand pays to use the service.

Speed with precision

A shortlist in two to four weeks is only worth it if it’s the right shortlist.

Brand first

The brand’s outcome is the only measure of a good match.

Ready to find the right agency?

Tell us what you’re trying to solve. We’ll introduce you to the agencies we’d call if it were our brand.

A quiet conversation space with red neon artwork